Stop pursuing happiness!

The circumstances of my life forced me to reevaluate “happiness.” Chronic ill health, two fatal diseases, and all the related sequelae – results or conditions that follow from a disease – robbed me of a career, romantic relationships, and my independence. An entry I once made in my journal reads: what is the point of me now?

The phrase “the pursuit of Happiness” in the American Declaration of Independence is misleading. We spend an extraordinary amount of our lives chasing happiness, yet the pursuit itself may be one of the principal obstacles to achieving it. We imagine happiness as a destination: something waiting for us when we have accumulated enough money, achieved sufficient success, found the right partner, secured our future, or finally arranged our lives to our satisfaction. We tell ourselves that once these things fall into place, we will be content.

But what if this assumption is fundamentally mistaken, as I believe it is? What if the relentless pursuit of happiness is actually making us unhappy?

The problem may be that we have come to regard happiness as something to acquire rather than something that emerges from the way we live. We have turned it into a personal project, another achievement to pursue and another standard against which to measure ourselves. In doing so, we risk becoming permanently dissatisfied with the present, always looking towards a future in which life will finally be as we want it to be.

There is an alternative, and it is considerably older than the modern self-help industry for which I have little use and much disdain. There was a time when philosophy was about how to live – about how to live well. This was the ancient Greek understanding of eudaimonia, the art of human flourishing, and it particularly occupied the philosophy of the Stoics. Its central proposition is deceptively simple: a good life does not depend on getting everything we want, but on learning to want less of what we cannot control, appreciate more of what we already have, and develop the character to deal wisely with whatever life brings.

This is not an argument for abandoning ambition, pleasure, or the desire to improve our circumstances. It is an argument for changing our understanding of what constitutes a successful life.

The modern conception of happiness is largely built around acquisition and achievement. We are encouraged to identify what is missing from our lives and then set about obtaining it. Happiness becomes conditional upon future circumstances.

The difficulty is that desire has no natural finishing point. Once we achieve one objective, another takes its place. The Stoics called this “the hedonic treadmill:” the new car becomes an ordinary possession, the promotion becomes the new baseline, and the financial security we once imagined would bring peace of mind becomes an invitation to accumulate still more.

Even success can become a source of anxiety because we become preoccupied with maintaining it.

This is the paradox: the more we condition our happiness on achieving particular outcomes, the more vulnerable we become to disappointment. We surrender our present contentment to an uncertain future.

The 19th century German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer, a bright light in my constellation of philosophers with something to say to me (although the hair was a bit much), understood this problem particularly well. His view of human existence was famously pessimistic. He argued that human beings are driven by an insatiable will: we desire things, experience frustration while pursuing them, obtain them, and then discover that satisfaction is temporary. Soon another desire emerges.

He described human existence as oscillating between pain and boredom. We suffer when we cannot obtain what we want, and when we finally obtain it, we discover that the pleasure does not last.

Although Schopenhauer’s conclusion was bleak, his diagnosis remains remarkably relevant. Much of our dissatisfaction comes not from what we lack but from the habit of continually identifying something else that we need.

The implication is profound. Perhaps happiness is not a matter of satisfying every desire, but of changing our relationship with desire itself.

Back to ancient Greece. The ancient Greeks approached the question of happiness rather differently. Their concept of eudaimonia is often translated as happiness, but it is better understood as human flourishing: living a life that fulfills our potential and reflects our deepest values.

For Aristotle, this meant exercising reason and developing virtues such as courage, justice, moderation, and wisdom. Happiness was not simply an emotional state or a succession of pleasurable experiences. It was the consequence of living well over the course of a lifetime.

The Stoics developed a particularly practical interpretation of this idea. For them, the good life was about living in accordance with reason and nature, cultivating character and recognizing the difference between what we can control and what we cannot. The distinction between happiness as a feeling and happiness as a way of life is fundamental.

We cannot guarantee that we will always feel happy. Life contains illness (tell me about it!), bereavement, rejection, disappointment, and uncertainty. No amount of positive thinking can eliminate these realities. But we can develop the wisdom to respond to them. We can choose to act with integrity, courage, kindness, and perspective, even when our circumstances are difficult.

This is the essence of eudaimonia. A good life is not necessarily a comfortable life. It is a life in which we develop the capacity to live well regardless of whether events conform to our expectations.

The Stoic philosophers Epictetus, Seneca, and Marcus Aurelius understood that our greatest freedom lies not in controlling the world but in governing our judgements, intentions, and actions.

One of their central insights was that it is not events themselves that disturb us, but the meanings and judgements we attach to them.

An adverse event can be painful, but we often compound that pain through the stories we tell ourselves. A professional setback becomes evidence that we are failures. A disagreement becomes proof that someone does not respect us. An unexpected change becomes a catastrophe because it disrupts the future we had imagined. The Stoic response is to examine these interpretations rather than automatically accepting them as reality.

This does not mean denying suffering or pretending that difficult experiences are unimportant. It means recognizing that the event itself and our response to it are not necessarily the same thing. We cannot always choose what happens, but we can work towards choosing how we understand it.

Perhaps the most liberating Stoic principle is the distinction between what is within our control and what is not.

Epictetus argued that our thoughts, judgements, intentions, and actions are fundamentally our own responsibility. Almost everything else is external: other people’s opinions, our reputation, our wealth, our health, the behavior of others, and the unpredictable events of the world.

Much of our unhappiness arises because we invest enormous emotional energy trying to control things that are not ours to control. We want other people to approve of us. We want relationships to unfold according to our expectations. We want our careers to progress without setbacks. We want our efforts to be recognized and rewarded. But none of these things is entirely within our power.

The Stoic alternative is not indifference. We should care about our relationships, work, health, and responsibilities. We should pursue worthwhile ambitions and make every reasonable effort to improve our circumstances. The difference is that we should not make our inner wellbeing dependent upon outcomes we cannot guarantee.

We can pursue a career without allowing professional success to define our worth. We can love another person without expecting to control their behavior. We can work towards financial security without believing that wealth will ultimately protect us from every uncertainty. This is a different kind of freedom: the freedom to participate fully in life without demanding that life always deliver the results we want.

Schopenhauer’s observations about desire also point toward another important source of unhappiness: our attachment to the way we imagine our lives should unfold – this was a big one for me.

We construct narratives about the future. We anticipate where we will live, what we will achieve, whom we will love, and how our circumstances will develop. These imagined futures become psychological reference points against which we judge our actual lives. But life rarely cooperates.

A useful way of thinking about this is to imagine our intentions as one direction of travel (X) and external circumstances as another (Y). The actual trajectory of our lives is a diagonal (Z) produced by the interaction between the two.

We can influence that trajectory, but we cannot determine it completely.

A relationship ends. An opportunity disappears. A business fails. A change in health or family circumstances redirects our priorities. These events may be painful, but they do not necessarily mean that our lives have gone wrong. The mistake is to become so attached to our intended destination that every deviation feels like a personal defeat.

The more rigidly we insist that life must follow our plans, the more frustrated we become when reality intervenes. A wiser approach is to retain our ambitions while remaining adaptable about the route. We should have direction without becoming prisoners of expectation.

This is one of the most important lessons I have learned: the quality of our lives is determined not only by where we intend to go, but by how intelligently and gracefully we respond to where we actually find ourselves.

The 16th century French philosopher Michel de Montaigne is another bright star in my philosophical constellation and he provides a valuable perspective on the art of living, with much more acceptable hair.

In his Essays, Montaigne explored human nature with unusual honesty, examining mortality, friendship, fear, habit, vanity, judgement, and the contradictions of his own personality.

He was not interested in presenting himself as a philosopher who had conquered human weakness. On the contrary, he was fascinated by the limitations and inconsistencies of human beings. His philosophy was one of self-examination, skepticism, and acceptance.

Montaigne was deeply influenced by ancient philosophy, particularly by… wait for it… the Stoics, whose writings he helped bring to renewed prominence during the Renaissance. He understood philosophy not as an abstract intellectual discipline but as a practical means of learning how to live.

His approach is especially relevant to the modern pursuit of happiness because he challenges our tendency to take ourselves and our own thoughts too seriously. We often assume that our feelings accurately describe reality. We believe that our anxieties are justified, that our ambitions are essential, and that our personal disappointments are evidence of some larger failure.

Montaigne encourages us to question these assumptions. Human beings are inconsistent, irrational, and frequently mistaken about themselves. A little humility and perspective can therefore be enormously liberating. He also reminds us that being human means accepting our imperfections. We are subject to fear, vanity, desire, jealousy, and uncertainty. A good life does not require us to eliminate these characteristics, but to understand them and avoid allowing them to dominate us.

There is something profoundly reassuring in this philosophy. We do not need to become perfect before we can live well.

If happiness is not something we can secure through future achievements, perhaps we should pay more attention to the life we are already living. One of the great ironies of modern existence is that we spend so much time preparing to enjoy life that we sometimes forget to enjoy it.

Remember, thoughtful reader:

don’t forget to smell the roses.

We work towards retirement, accumulate possessions, pursue professional recognition, and postpone pleasure until some imagined point of financial or personal security. Meanwhile, the ordinary experiences that constitute much of a good life pass almost unnoticed. A walk (or roll in my case!), a conversation, a good movie, a meal with friends, time spent reading, or simply enjoying an afternoon without any particular objective can provide a quiet form of contentment that no achievement can guarantee.

But being present does not mean abandoning the future or living exclusively for pleasure. Human flourishing requires purpose, responsibility, and meaningful relationships as well as enjoyment.

The important distinction is between pursuing meaningful objectives and making our happiness conditional upon achieving them.

We can work towards something worthwhile while still appreciating the present. We can have ambitions without being consumed by them. We can recognize that life is valuable not simply because of what it may eventually deliver, but because of what it offers now. This is the difference between living and merely preparing to live.

The central paradox of happiness is that the more desperately we pursue it as a personal objective, the more elusive it becomes.

When we make happiness conditional upon success, wealth, recognition, comfort, or the approval of others, we give away our contentment to circumstances we cannot fully control. We become dependent on an ever-changing collection of external conditions, and we postpone satisfaction until some future moment when everything is finally right.

The ancient Stoics offer a more sustainable alternative. Rather than attempting to control the external world, they encourage us to develop control over our judgements, intentions, and actions. Rather than endlessly pursuing pleasure, they invite us to cultivate wisdom, courage, moderation, and justice. Rather than measuring life by the extent to which it satisfies our expectations, they suggest measuring it by the quality of the person we become.

Schopenhauer helps us recognize the futility of endless desire. Montaigne teaches us humility and self-knowledge. The Stoics show us how to translate these insights into a practical philosophy of everyday living.

Together, these ideas suggest that happiness is not a prize awarded to those who successfully arrange their lives. It is a by-product of learning to live intelligently with the lives we actually have. This does not mean abandoning the desire to improve our circumstances, accepting injustice, or becoming passive in the face of adversity. It means distinguishing between constructive action and futile resistance to reality.

There is a profound difference between wanting life to be better and believing that life must be better before we can be content.

Perhaps the real objective is not to become permanently happy, but to become less dependent on happiness as we have traditionally understood it. To live with purpose, but without obsession. To pursue success, but without making our self-worth dependent upon it. To enjoy pleasure, but without expecting it to last forever. To accept disappointment without allowing it to define us. To appreciate what we have rather than constantly measuring it against what we lack.

The ancient Greeks called this eudaimonia: the flourishing that comes from living well.

And perhaps that is the great paradox of happiness: we are most likely to find it when we stop treating it as something to be pursued and start treating the quality of our lives as something to be practiced.